Lawsuit was perhaps the biggest 90s band you’ve never heard of. Hailing from the cow-infested university town of Davis, California, the ten piece self-styled ska-jazz-punk-bubblegum band was perhaps too revolutionary for their time.
Third-wave ska washed over the indie scene in the early 1990s, spilling over occasionally into more commercially successful music: The Mighty Mighty Bosstones and Reel Big Fish came in with this tide, among others. Lawsuit was certainly buoyed by ska’s semi-underground popularity at this time, yet they never could be cleanly pigeonholed as ska, nor any of the other genres they borrowed from. Their genre-bending sound was purely their own: bouncy and brassy, spicy power-pop so salsa you’d dip chips into it if you could possibly find a way to stop dancing. Perfectly suited for any combination of skanking, waltzing, tangoing, moshing, and/or white-boy head-bobbing.
While the recordings never fully captured the magic of their live shows, they remain as precious relics of a band that deserved far more exposure than they got. For years they consistently packed venues across California, but their unclassifiable nature made record labels shrink in fear. Perhaps if their album Emergency Third Rail Power Trip had been released in today’s climate of nichier tastes and fewer gatekeepers, Lawsuit could have wound up bigger than Coldplay. We’ll never know what might have been, but we can still enjoy the gifts they did leave us.
Their dense and quirky lyrics are a perfect match for the nasally tenor of their front man, the late Paul Sykes — sounding equal parts David Byrne and Fred Schneider — winding punful swifties into the DNA of peculiar characters and situations, familiar and stylized tidbits of everyday life.
This doctor has me on hold
His hypocritical oath, his hippopotamus house
He’s at the petting zoo tomorrow with a hyperactive child
Their craftiest and most ambitious work of wordplay comes in the album opener, “North Dakotachrome”, which embeds the names of numerous U.S. states, Canadian provinces, and other North American place names, such as how Washington, Yukon, Kansas, and Oregon find their way into
I go washing tons of clothing
And you contact me there
Can this be the ending
Or a gone berserk affair?
Merry angst infuses “The Complaint Song”, with each of the four verses lamenting a different irritant that has timelessly tormented humanity. It could easily be a dirge if it lacked the horns, bouncy rhythm, bubblegum vocals, or melody; fortunately, we are instead left with a chipper quartet of mini-rants that turns out to be far more listenable. A similar collision of perky ennui permeates “Useless Flowers”, “Stoplite”, and “Entropy”, the latter of which practically begs to be a choreographed dance number in a 1920s speakeasy.
So get somewhere that you can safely tap your toes without too much social awkwardness, give Lawsuit a good cross-examination, and judge for yourself. Most of their discography, along with some of their alumni’s various side projects, are available for free or cheap download.
MP3: Thank God You’re Doing Fine
MP3: North Dakotachrome
MP3: The Complaint Song
Download album: Emergency Third Rail Power Trip (1993)